Home arrow Archives arrow Open Forum
 
Home
News and Features
INFA Digest
Parliament Spotlight
Dossiers
Publications
Journalism Awards
Archives
RSS
 
 
 
 
 
 
Open Forum
Ayodhyanomics Energises UP: LIGHTING UP THE GRAY AREA, By Shivaji Sarkar, 22 January 2024 Print E-mail

Economic Highlights

New Delhi, 22 January 2024

Ayodhyanomics Energises UP

LIGHTING UP THE GRAY AREA

By Shivaji Sarkar 

Ayodhyanomics unveils an ambitious vision with Rs 85,000 crore investment for the township of 30 lakh people, as majestic Rs 1800 crore Ramlala Mandir sets to open on January 22 amidst grand celebrations and inauguration by Prime Minister Narendra Modi.It is wonder economics. The state government invests a mere Rs 20 crore for Ayodhya for housing schemes and the largesse goes to Agra and Varanasi, Rs 400 crore each, Moradabad and Meerut Rs 200 crore each, New Kanpur Rs 170 crore of a toral Rs 3000 crore allocation for housing schemes. 

The Sri Ram Janmabhoomi Teerth Kshetra Trust estimates the cost at Rs 1800 crore to be met from an approximate collection of Rs 5500 crore. This is swelling.More than its economics, the politics around Ram keeps people more engaged. Not only the BJP sees it as the trump religious card, even the Opposition finds it uncomfortable, if not troublesome to handle. 

The small township of less than 5 square km sees flurry of activity to welcome an estimated 45 lakh visitors and the Ayodhya commissioner says it would see an investment boost of Rs 85000 crore over the next ten years. This is largely an estimation. The dream is of turning it into a hub to rest on 178 projects and an array of various levels of hotels, OYO with 1000 beds to a number of 5-star hotels. 

A contrast is Jagdishpur industrial hub, 66 km from Ayodhya, attempted to be developed in 1980s by Sanjay Gandhi and after him Rajiv Gandhi with thousands of crores of public sector investments. The latest of that was in the 2012 plan for creating a food hub. It all collapsed partly for it being an interior area and largely for unsustainable business model and as some alleged because of unfavourable political atmosphere. 

Ayodhya is seeing building of roads, bridges, new railway station, airport to water metro service and similar other facilities and cultural centre.The redevelopment of Ayodhya, as envisaged in Master Plan 2031, broadly hinges on eight themes to guide civic authorities for the upcoming smart city. The scheme includes a spiritual university, a green-field township, an urban forest, to name a few. Other highlights include a central business district, hotels, riverfront, water bodies, and dharmshalas. The footfall as of now is said to be around 30000 a month. 

Property prices, as per industry sources, have risen nearly four times over the past three years. Top five-star hotel brands such as the Taj, Radisson, ITC are opening new properties to cater to the projected rise in demand. In fact, over 73 new hotels are in the pipeline in Ayodhya. A new property, Ayodhya Tent City, has also come up and offers stay at luxurious tents.   

Indian Hotels (IHCL) launched two new hotels in Ayodhya under the Vivanta and Ginger brands. Both are greenfield projects in partnership with Bhardwaj Global Infraventures. “Ayodhya is an important pilgrimage site and likely to receive high footfall throughout the year. These hotels will also complete the travel circuit with Lucknow and Varanasi”, IHCL said in a statement.

Interestingly, civic authorities are projecting a ratio of 1:10 of residents to tourists. According to industry estimates, around 3.25 lakh tourists visited Ayodhya in 2021 and the following year this number rose to 2.39 crore. Now, after the inauguration of the temple, local authorities are expecting over 4 crore pilgrims to visit Ayodhya this year.The state-government has promised that the holy town will become a world-class city in the coming years with modern amenities around its cultural aesthetics. 

There are 324 five-star hotels in the country. Agra is said to have a dozen, but they do rarely have full occupancy as most people prefer to stay in Delhi and make short trips. Vrindavan a popular pilgrim centre has no 5-star accommodation. Pilgrims spend moderately. The ground breaking ceremony in Ayodhya, scheduled for February, will launch 126 hospitality sector projects worth Rs 3,800 crore. This includes four mega projects, including hotels and resorts. The largest investments in the district are in the hospitality sector, totalling Rs 420 crore. Out of the 126 projects, 46 have MoUs signed, worth Rs 1,923 crore. 

Ayodhya has been one of the low priority stations for most devouts. The hype created would need efforts to sustain. The government investment is low and so far, it seemingly has not much of an industrial activity planned. The flow of tourists at ratio 1:10 or residents would be the only factor for sustaining an economy. 

The political atmosphere contributes a lot to sustain a project. Jagdishpur, launched with much fanfare did not succeed. The region was planned to become an industrial hub and public sector companies were forced to setup factories in the region, irrespective of feasibility and concerns of profitability. Many big PSUs like SAIL, HAL, BHEL and thousands of small companies set up units in the area out of political compulsions. The region flourished as the PSUs pumped money to set up factories but in less than a decade, decline began as almost all the 135 units turned out to be unprofitable because the region is not feasible for industrial development. Even Malvika Steel, a Rs1500 crore mega plant of SAIL and Rourkela Steel collapsed despite central government financial support from 2012 to 2014. 

Similarly, Amethi, 100 km away from Ayodhya suffered what congressmen say, “politics of revenge” and BJP minister Smriti Irani says unviable projects pushed by the UPA government. The few projects that could ultimately be propped up failed to bring about the promised growth and development. The fate of several projects pushed by UPA 2 in its final months now hang in balance. 

Small traders are having a spurt in business. There is growing demand for handicrafts such as decorative pendants, bangles, lockets, key rings, garlands, among others. Exports from Ayodhya, according to reports, rose by 130 percent to Rs254 crore in 2023. 

Ayodhya has not much of public investments. It is designed mostly to survive on private investments. Dinesh Goyal, Vice President, Indian Industries Association, told the press that he expects a business turnover of Rs50,000 crore because of ongoing preparations ahead of opening ceremonies at Ram Mandir. Business entities across the country are capitalising on these opportunities. A tall order or not, the unfolding developments beyond the temple consecration would reveal.---INFA 

(Copyright, India News & Feature Alliance)

 

India & Maldives: SOCIAL MEDIA WAR, By Dr. D.K. Giri, January 2024 Print E-mail

Round The World

New Delhi, 19 January 2024

India & Maldives

SOCIAL MEDIA WAR

By Dr. D.K. Giri

(Secretary General, Assn for Democratic Socialism) 

Digital technology is a wonderful invention and social media is a powerful platform. But remember, EF Schumacher had propounded the concept of appropriate technology which is defined by judicious use of any technology by its consumers. In the India-Maldives relations, the recent unsavoury spat in the social media backed by a dose of hyper nationalism on both sides is a classic case of overuse if not crass abuse of social media. Unfortunately, both the countries have perhaps unconsciously allowed the social media to influence negatively the bilateral relations. 

The fracas began with absolutely uncalled for reactions by three Maldivian ministers to snapshots posted by Prime Minister Modi of his trip to Lakshadweep. Even in the words of former President of Maldives, Ibrahim Solih that the ministers used ‘hateful language’. Of course, the Maldives government immediately suspended the ministers. 

Nevertheless, in reaction to the derogatory personal comments by the Maldivian ministers on Indian Prime Minister, all hell broke loose on the Indian social media. A fairly big travel agency EaseMyTrip CEO reacted by cancelling thousands of bookings by Indian tourists to Maldives. Another Indian travel aggregator removed Male as a destination from its travel website and encouraged tourists to go instead for Indian beaches. BJP IT cell unleashed its troll army to take on Maldives. It roped in its favourite acquiescent celebrities from sports and cinema – Amitabh Bachchan, Akshay Kumar, Virender Sehwag, Sachin Tendulkar – ironically the very people who holiday in Maldives.  

A South Indian film star Nagarjuna cancelled his entire family’s visit to Maldives in support of the Prime Minister and the country. The troll army used demeaning language in attacking Maldives. The point is, was it necessary to disparage Maldives while promoting Lakshadweep and other holidays spots in India. The outburst of nationalism against a small neighbouring country, which has been friendly and dependent on India was equally uncalled for. Worse, a commerce organisation has said they would not trade with Maldives. 

The patriotic cheerleaders and social media warriors are oblivious of two important elements in the recent episode. One is presenting Lakshadweep as an alternative to Maldives. There is no doubt that there are several wonderful, underused tourist spots in India. How to promote tourism to such areas is another discussion. It should be noted that Lakshadweep is a small archipelago located in 32 sq kms, quite small to absorb numerous footfalls. It is an ecologically sensitive zone that contains the carbon footprint in the Island. It has, as of now, very little connectivity. There is one daily 60-seater flight from Kochi to Agatti. Only two of five ferries sail between Kochi and Lakshadweep. There are barely 100 rooms across the Island. Lakshadweep is certainly exquisite. But the question is whether average Indian tourists always game for food and shopping will find much attraction. 

The second issue is the comprehension of Maldivian politics, especially after the election of President Mohamed Muizzu having a pro-China tilt. Muizzu ran his campaign on an ‘India Out’ plank. A correct perception of the recent political developments in Maldives should help steady the India-Maldives bilateral relations. Let us not forget that Maldives politics is divided like that of any other country. All Maldivians or political parties are not against India. The Opposition parties are vigorously protesting the anti-India positioning by the present Maldivian government. In fact, there have been calls for a no-confidence motion against the ruling regime. Even a Maldivian tourism body wrote to their Indian counterparts, “We want you to know the bonds connecting our nations transcend politics. We consider our Indian counterparts as cherish brothers and sisters”. 

Maldives economy is run largely by its tourism. India is by far the largest source of tourism for Maldives. So, the panic, even if we discount the pro-Indian feeling in anti-Muizzu political segments, is understandable. In 2023, over two lakh tourists from India landed in Maldives that has around 5 lakh people. Even in the pandemic, 63000 Indians visited Maldives. Over last two years, 4.5 lakh Indians have been to Maldives. President Muizzu asserted that Maldives can substitute Indian tourists by an increase in the flow of tourists from China. Apparently, he made a request to Chinese President Xi Jinping to send more tourists to his country. It is hard to imagine that China can literally turn on a tap that increases the flow of tourists to any destination. 

Let us also remember that leadership in many countries in the India-Pacific region is divided as pro or anti-China. Those who are anti-China seem to be pro-India and vice-e-versa. The countries that come to mind are Sri Lanka, Nepal, Bangladesh, Maldivies and so on. The External Affairs Minister S. Jaishankar in an event in Nagpur reacted to the journalists on the recent tension with Maldives. He also suggested that small countries try to leverage the big power rivalries. Admittedly, India has been doing so in case of former Soviet Union, now Russia and the United States. So, some countries including Maldives do the same between India and China. 

Indians should be conscious of the geo-political dynamics that prompt regimes in countries to choose partners. New Delhi should focus on its tension and competition with China which are reflected in our relations with our neighbours and other countries in the region. Beijing, in the pursuit of its policy of ‘String of Pearls’, is penetrating into India’s neighbourhood. New Delhi has to counter it with all its force - diplomatic, economic and strategic. This is a strategic choice imposed on India which it cannot forswear. 

On repairing the current rupture in India-Maldives relations, both countries have to reflect and react. As a bigger country, India could be more tolerant by being a bit thick-skinned. Outsized reactions as were seen in the social media should be avoided. Maldivians should realise that India has been their trusted ally and a provider of essential goods and services. New Delhi has helped Maldives on several crisis situations in addition to having multi-sectoral projects in the country. China may come with a bigger pot of money, but as other countries have realised, alliance with China is like a kiss of death. Beijing seduces countries with instant aid and draws them into a debt trap. 

Geographically, Maldives is 700 kms from the Indian coast and over 6000 kms from China. New Delhi treats Maldives as an important part of SAGAR (Security and Growth for All in the Region) Policy. A robust long-term relation with India will augur well for Maldives. Likewise, India would benefit from the strategic location of Maldives in the Indian Ocean. Beijing has been wooing Maldives for the same reason as 80 per cent of China’s oil passes through the maritime trade highway through Maldives. 

To conclude, New Delhi should take urgent steps to repair the damage. The China angle in India’s neighbourhood is not new. The situation has been similar in Nepal. But the regime change has retrieved it for India. Maldives could be no exception. India’s foreign policy is more progressive than China’s. President Muizzu would have a change of mind or Maldives will have a change of regime. Indians should therefore react with caution and maturity.---INFA 

(Copyright, India News & Feature Alliance)

 

 

Bharat JodoNyay Yatra: ASSAM GIVES HOPE TO CONG, By Insaf, 20 January 2024 Print E-mail

Round The States

New Delhi, 20 January 2024

Bharat Jodo NyayYatra

ASSAM GIVES HOPE TO CONG

By Insaf 

BJP-ruled Assam has pleasantly surprised the Congress, rather given a fillip to Rahul Gandhi’s ‘Bharat JodoNyayYatra,’kicked off from Manipur. “Women assembled for a function organised by the Assam CM in Mariani spontaneously and enthusiastically met @RahulGandhi on Day 5 of the BJNY. NYAY for Assam has begun!” read the party’s X post. Indeed, as a large number of rural women in Jorhat, who had gathered to collect forms for a newly announced government scheme were seen leaving their queues to greet Rahul, who had reached Mariani town from neighbouring Sivasagar district around Thursday noon. The video on social media showed women showering affection and sought to click pictures with him, before he proceeded further. 

The response has triggered a bitter controversy. Congress has accused Chief Minister Sarma trying to derail the yatra. First by creating obstacles, such as fixing dates for the distribution of forms in such a manner that it deliberately clashed with Rahul yatra and second having an FIR registered suomoto by the police against the yatra and its chief organiser KB Byju for allegedly ‘deviating from its permitted route inside Jorhat town,’ leading to chaos. Whereas, the Congress said ‘the assigned route was too small, and we had a huge gathering. So, we took a detour for just a few metres... Sarma wants to make the yatra a flop.” Who is more successful, is anybody’s guess. The yatra has 17 districts on its schedule in the state till January 25 and there’s bound to be more heat and dust raised. But all eyes are on the big story—preparations for D-Day, January 22 and Ayodhya. The twist and turns the yatra takes, must take a backseat, at least till then.

*                                               *                                   *                                                           * 

Chandigarh Mayor Poll Drama

Chandigarh mayoral elections have kicked up a storm. The AAP and Congress have accused BJP of not allowing these to be held under fear of its “imminent defeat”! Thursday should have seen a new civic team, but the polls were abruptly postponed on ‘pretext’ the presiding office Anil Masih, had fallen sick. After high drama outside municipal corporation office and filing of a petition in Punjab & Haryana High Court by AAP, the DC announced February 6 as the next date of poll. Interestingly, he has nominated Masih as presiding officer, giving credence to allegations that “BJP sent him to hospital” as “majority of officers responsible for the election, including presiding officer and secretary, municipal corporation, belong to the Haryana cadre, where BJP is in power, and they are under party’s influence.” All this, because this election was being viewed as the first test between INDIA bloc and BJP as both AAP and Congress reached an understanding -- AAP to field mayor candidate, while Congress to contest for senior deputy mayor and deputy mayor posts. So, if voting went as per party lines, then their 20 combined votes were sufficient to defeat BJP, which since past 8 years has held the mayor’s post. The postponement not only saves BJP the embarrassment but gives it time to work on ‘Operation Lotus’, says opposition. Will February 6th prove it right? 

*                                               *                                   *                                                           * 

System Fails Rural Kids

The education system in the country has failed the rural kids! The Annual Status of Education Report (ASER) 2023 ‘Beyond Basics’ by NGO Pratham released on Wednesday, following a survey in 28 districts across 26 States reveals not much has changed over the decade and kids continue to struggle with basic reading and arithmetic skills well into teenage years. Specifically, 42% of children aged 14 to 18 years in rural India can’t read easy sentences in English; over half can’t even solve simple 3-digit division problems, usually taught in 3-4th standard; about 25% can’t read a class 2 level text fluently in their regional language! While there’s lot more statistics from 34,745-youth surveyed, the message for Government is: ‘Catch up efforts for foundational literacy and numeracy are needed…not only for doing better in school but also for everyday needs.’ Shockingly, it has done precious little, despite its NEP 2020 stating, ‘urgent need for ensuring that by Std III, children have acquired basic reading and arithmetic skills.” Time it did its own homework right!

*                                               *                                   *                                                           * 

Cong AP Comeback?

The Congress is desperately trying to make a comeback in Andhra Pradesh. Less than two weeks of YS Sharmila, sister of Chief Minister YS Jagan Reddy Mohan and daughter of former CM Y S Rajasekhar Reddy, joining the party, it appointed her as President of the state unit on Tuesday last, and compensated outgoing chief GiduguRudraRaju, as special invitee to the CWC. The change,just before general and Assembly elections may not go down well with old timers, but the party doesn’t have much to lose. Since 2014, it has failed to get a single MLA or MP elected, so even if Sharmila can score a small success, the party can pat itself. A lot, however, depends on how she changes the label of ‘belonging to Telangana’ and lay a claim to YSR’s political legacy in the State, which brother Jagan has used to his advantage to the hilt. Political analysts do not give the Congress much space as the battle is clearly between YSR Congress and the TDP. Sharmila has a long way to go, starting with testing the waters within the grand old party itself.

*                                               *                                   *                                                           * 

Bihar Largesse

Bihar government is wasting no time to woo the voters. On Tuesday last, Chief Minister Nitish Kumar announced the Laghu Udyami Yojana,(Bihar small entrepreneur scheme)wherein one member of each family, earning less than Rs 6000 per month (9.4 million families), will get Rs 2 lakh over five years. The first of three instalments was sanctioned by the Cabinet i.e., Rs 50,000, to be disbursed next month to five lakh families selected through a computerised randomisation process‘to set up and run small industrial or processing units, such as handicraft, textile, saloon, eateries, among 63 types of units.’ The schemewill be implemented by industries department, and members of such families will need to apply online and produce the proof of family income to claim benefits. Another scheme approved was of providing one-time financial grant ranging from 75,000 to 30,000 to students from EBC families preparing for civil services (mains) exams. There is a catch though. A lot will hinge on budgetary allocations. The big question being where will these additional thousands of crores come from? ---INFA 

(Copyright, India News & Feature Alliance)

 

Opposition Unity And V.P. Singh, By Inder Jit, 18 January 2024 Print E-mail

REWIND

New Delhi, 18 January 2024

Opposition Unity And V.P. Singh

By Inder Jit

(Released on 11 October 1988)

All those interested in seeing a strong Opposition emerge as a credible alternative to the Congress-I at the national level will need to keep their fingers crossed. The Janata, Lok Dal-B, Congress-S and Jan Morcha are due to meet at a foundation conference at Bangalore today to launch their unified party to be called Samajwadi or Rashtriya Janata Dal. High drama preceded this meeting during the past fortnight and more. On occasions, the unified party appeared to be coming through. On others, its formation looked like going up in smoke. It was touch and go on Monday last week when the Steering Committee failed to meet. Hopes revived when the Committee met a day later on Tuesday. But a question mark again went up over its future by Friday night. Fortunately, Mr. V.P. Singh, backed by Mr. R.K. Hegde, Mr. Biju Patnaik and many others, persevered in their decision to hold the party’s foundation conference on October 11, birth anniversary of Jayaprakash Narayan. Nevertheless, one question remains. Will the leaders merely pay lip service to the Lok Nayak or will they truly emulate JP and put the country before self?

The problem is the unified party’s leadership has been resolved in favour of Mr. V.P. Singh, notwithstanding some unnecessary and graceless remarks reportedly made by Mr. Chandra Shekhar. Mr. Singh is undoubtedly the Opposition’s best bet today for the next general election. He is widely viewed as a fine person and a man of character and probity, unaffected by sharp Congress-I attacks on him and his policies. But he has still to show that he has vision and qualities of leadership required for guiding our huge country of over 800 million people and for providing a good government. (Remember, self-government is no substitute for good government!) Candidly, his popular image today no longer shines as brightly as it did when he founded the Jan Morcha or impressively triumphed over the Congress-I in the Allahabad by-election to the Lok Sabha in mid-June. Even his friends and known supporters are concerned, if not worried. Willy nilly, he seems at the moment to have needlessly reduced himself to the level of the other Opposition leaders, most of whom have little charisma and even less credibility.

Many Opposition leaders feel that “VP” has not shown the decisiveness and boldness expected of him as the new leader in the past few weeks. Mr. Singh, they argue, was given full authority by the Janata, Lok Dal-B, Congress-S and Jan Morcha to go ahead and form the unified party --- the SJD and a Steering Committee. But the exercise has left much to be desired and, in the bargain, not only raised doubts over the unity moves but even given a convenient handle to persons who have been basking in his reflected glory during the past year to attack him publicly. One can understand Mr. Singh’s desire to carry the leaders of all the four parties with him in the footsteps of JP. I recall his telling me some time back that the real art of politics lies in the management of disharmony and not just of harmony. However, the outcome so far has been far from flattering. The Steering Committee and its composition has not inspired much confidence, apart from the fact that it has attracted avoidable flak and created an impression of superficial ad hocism and absence of a national perspective. Surprisingly, Mr. Singh failed to consult all those concerned.

The Steering Committee, intended to be the nucleus of the new party, is dominated by persons from UP and the rest of the Hindi States. True, the Hindi heartland is crucial for winning the next poll battle. Nevertheless, the Committee needed to be more representative of various regions and special interests such as the minorities, women and youth. Surprisingly, the South is represented only by Mr. Hegde and Mr. K.P. Unnikrishnan, who hails from Kerala. Maharashtra, Punjab and West Bengal, too, are unrepresented. (Prof. Madhu Dandavate has been included only as a special invitee) Equally surprisingly, women are conspicuous by their absence. Several names come to mind easily, especially those of Mr. Mrinal Gore and Mrs. Premila Dandavate. The Committee’s strength could have been increased to at least 2 and even to 31 and not limited to 17, a figure which had no special sanctity. Advantage should have been taken of the experience and approach of the pre-independence Congress. Its Working Committee normally comprised 21 members plus some special invitees, if necessary.

The Opposition leaders have none but themselves to blame if their image has slumped and fresh doubts have arisen about their ability to provide credible alternative to the Congress-I. Far too many among them have been speaking out of turn --- often at cross purposes. Far too many meetings have been handled tactlessly, leading to avoidable heart-burning. A case in point is the meeting of the Steering Committee, which failed to be held on October 3. It should have been convened only after differences had been ironed out and ground work completed. Failure to hold the meeting only tarnished the image of the Opposition at a time when it desperately needs to win friends and influence people. Mr. Singh should have striven to ensure that there was no confusion over the Jan Morcha’s stand in regard to the basic issue of unity, leading to messy situation in which Mr. Ram Dhan felt emboldened to publicly attack Mr. Singh as well as the entire leadership of the Janata, Lok Dal-B and Congress-S and denounce it in astonishingly strong terms.

Not a little of the blame must go to Chandra Shekhar. Undoubtedly, Mr. Chandra Shekhar is a man of ideals and has not few other admirable qualities which made JP choose him as the youthful President of the Janata Party in 1977. Sadly, however, he has allowed his unrequited ambition to run away with his better sense and the ideal of selflessness advocated by his mentor --- JP. Instead of helping the Opposition parties to come together in response to popular demand, he has been dragging his feet and seems to have left no stratagem untried to block unity and “VP”. Mercifully, he did turn up at the Steering Committee meeting on Wednesday last even if he was late by an hour. He also greed to the persuasion of Mr. Singh and Mr. Hegde to head the Sub-Committee set up to draw up the SJD’s policies and programmes. But his attitude at the meeting and subsequently has left on observers the clear impression that he has been out to “delay if not sabotage” the birth of the unified party at its foundation conference on October 11. At one stage, he even wanted it called only the “sponsoring conference.”

Mr. Chandra Shekhar was theoretically correct when he said some weeks back that the Opposition should seek to provide an alternative to the Congress-I and Mr. Rajiv Gandhi and not merely substitute. He, therefore, insisted that the proposed unified party and its policies and programmes were more important than Mr. Singh as the new leader. But this stand ignored certain practical realities in a country like India which continues to be soaked in feudal ethos. What ultimately counts here is the individual who leads a party and not the party and its policies and programmes. Nothing illustrates this more than the great success which the Congress achieved under the charismatic leadership first of Mahatma Gandhi, and thereafter under Nehru, Indira Gandhi and Mr. Rajiv Gandhi. The Janata Paty, too, won its great victory in 1977 because of JP and his leadership. Equally illustrative is the dismal failure of the CPI and CPM to make any great impact. The CPM has, no doubt, continued to achieve remarkable success in West Bengal. But the credit for this goes mainly to the personal popularity of its top leader, Mr. Jyoti Basu.

In retrospect, many wish that Mr. Singh had heeded the advice of some of his trusted friends and founded a new party, instead of taking on the sticky job of unifying the Opposition. He could have transformed the Jan Morcha from what Mr. V.C. Shukla smartly described as “a transit lounge” to a full-fledged party with a constitution and a policy. He could then have invited individual members of the Opposition as also intellectuals, academicians and professionals to join the new party. Alternatively, he could have invited the Opposition parties to merge with the Jan Morcha. In other words, he could (and should) have called the shots. There is little doubt that most of the rank and file of these parties would have gladly jumped on to his bandwagon, leaving their leaders high and dry. Mr. Singh could have thereby saved himself the trouble of having to knock time and again on the doors of Mr. Chandra Shekhar, Mr. Bahuguna and some others. In essence, he would have taken over the Opposition armies and forced their Generals either to surrender or take retirement.

Popular opinion increasingly favours a strong Opposition. Even those who continue to stand for Mr. Rajiv Gandhi feel that such an Opposition would be in the best interest of the ruling Congress-I and the country. Much ultimately will depend upon the quality of leadership Mr. Singh is able to provide and the success with which he and his supporters can neutralize the mischief of those who are unreconciled to his leadership and are certain to prevent him from functioning effectively. Bangalore could help resurrect JP‘s dream provided the Lok Nayak’s not remembered only ritually. He needs to be followed in practice and in action, in sharp and distressing contrast to the happenings after the Janata Government came to power in 1977. As we all know, JP died a sad and disillusioned person. Mr. Chandra Shekhar, Mr. Bahuguna and several others owe it to the Lok Nayak to give the country a credible alternative to the Congress-I, having failed to prevent the collapse of the Janata Government in 1979. It is time for them and other veterans to see the writing on the wall and, like Mr. Devi Lal, make way for the younger leaders --- and the new heroes. ---INFA

(Copyright, India News and Feature Alliance)

Ram Temple Consecration: FAREWELL TO SECULARISM?, By Dhurjati Mukherjee, 17 January 2024 Print E-mail

Open Forum

New Delhi, 17 January 2024

Ram Temple Consecration

FAREWELL TO SECULARISM?

By Dhurjati Mukherjee 

The consecration of the Ram temple on January 22 may well have the country anoint a Hindu religious city in Ayodhya like the Vatican City of the Christians or Mecca of the Muslims, though it has always boasted of being secular. The Father of the nation, Mahatma Gandhi, or even his direct followers and philosophers could have never imagined that secularism would yield place to majoritarianism-- the transformation that has taken place in the last decade raising a lot of heat and dust. 

Apart from the allegation that the consecration of the temple has been timed just before the Lok Sabha elections, what is more surprising is the Prime Minister’s claim that God had chosen him as “an instrument to represent all Indians during the consecration”. This, in response to questions being raised over his pre-eminence at the event. Modi said he had begun his 11-day special observance as prescribed in the scriptures to “awaken divine consciousness” within himself in the lead-up to the consecration. However, he did not specify what he meant by special observance.  

Though the secular spirit is now being slowly vanishing from society, Mahatma Gandhi himself never went to a Hindu temple. Only once he visited the Meenakshi temple in Madurai in 1946 after the shrine was opened to Dalits to enter the premises. Though Gandhiji described himself as a Hindu, his writings bear testimony to his profound religious feelings, his understanding of Hinduism which was completely different from what we see today and his chosen mode of worship was inter-faith meetings, held in open grounds where Hindus, Muslims, Parsis, Sikhs, Jains and Christians would pray together from verses of all scriptures. The Mahatma tried to show that India belonged to all faiths equally and propagated the essence of different religious faiths and doctrines.  

The Mahatma believed in the plurality of religions and abhorred any concept of the superiority of some races or religions. Stressing the need for equal respect for all religions, Gandhiji observed: “While I believe myself to be a Hindu, I know that I do not worship God in the same manner as any one or all of them”. This perception of the Mahatma cannot be said to be the majority view in the society today. The ruling dispensation has made us believe that we should be proud of our religion and in the process, denigrate other religions and the sentiments of those who do not subscribe to the Hindu line of thinking.  

It would be pertinent here to mention that just a few days back, over 3000 Christians from across the country registered a protest against community leaders’ culpable silence on minority rights and other grim realities while participating in the Prime Minister’s Christmas celebrations. In an open letter released recently, it stated: “The hard truth is that the Prime Minister and his government have consistently disregarded their constitutional mandate, be it to the minorities, the Adivasis, the Dalits, the backward castes, the farmers, labourers, migrants etc. hence their gratitude to the Prime Minister was not in our name”. 

The letter further emphasised that since 2014; in particular, Christians in India have been victims of continued attacks and vilification from members of the ruling establishment across the country. It was indeed distressing to note that the letter even referred to Christians and Christian schools which “have been hounded and harassed, their places of worship destroyed, they have been denied their ordinary rights as citizens and been subjected to denigration and demonisation.” 

If this happens to be the attitude of the Christian community, one can easily presume how the Muslims have been treated or, to use the right phrase humiliated, and what they think of the present government and its attitude towards the minorities. Obviously, the present genre of Muslims cannot be blamed for what their forefathers have done, and they have a right to life, being citizens of this democratic country. 

This brings us to the moot question i.e., while Ram is being worshipped and a grand temple being built in his honour, can the country claim to have introduced ‘ram rajya’ in India. The answer obviously is a big no. The ruling dispensation has been rather poor in matters of governance and the entire development process has largely ignored the lower echelons of society. The bottom tiers of society have been greatly affected as the disparity in society has widened. Not just income disparity between the rich and the poor but also between the urban and the rural class, between the formal and the informal sectors, between industrial workers and farmers etc. In the context of such development, all talks of India emerging the third largest economy by virtue of increased wealth of business tycoons such as Ambanis, Adanis and the Tatas appear meaningless. 

Truth, justice, equality are steadily vanishing from today’s society where violence, jealousy and hatred is manifest. Thus, while eulogising Ram without following the principles that he stood for and the way he ruled his kingdom smacks of nothing but hypocrisy. Moreover, unlike Swami Vivekananda, Lord Ram is just a mythological figure as the Anthropological Survey of India (ASI) did not find any scientific evidence of Ayodhya being his birthplace.  

Moreover, religion has always been regarded as a private affair, but the ruling dispensation has made it a political issue, obviously to reap benefits from the coming Lok Sabha elections due shortly. While the Congress has decided to boycott the inauguration on these grounds, the three Shankaracharyas have also decided to skip the event for being held against what they consider scripture-mandated norms. 

It may be mentioned here that Jawaharlal Nehru had adopted a stance, underlining the need for the State to keep its distance from religion. However, the current Prime Minister has projected himself as the sole guarantor of Hindu religion and his party, along with the RSS, to propagate and spread Hinduism in the world, though of a distorted version, much different from Vivekananda’s approach of unity of all religion. 

A section of political analysts and sociologists are quite surprised at the trajectory of the country’s political development to being a Hindu state. All the fanfare about the Ram temple is just to ensure that the BJP is assured of a landslide victory in the elections. And this is destined to happen as education and awareness has yet to trickle down to the masses in the backward areas of the country. They leave their destiny to the almighty.---INFA 

(Copyright, India News & Feature Alliance)

<< Start < Previous 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 Next > End >>

Results 91 - 99 of 5990
 
   
     
 
 
  Mambo powered by Best-IT